THE FINANCE CONFESSIONAL
Step into the confessional.
Finance often hears about changes last, and still has to explain them first. These are the case files: finance people, in their own words, with the names blacked out and the early signal behind each one.
"I decide what a booking is"
Six weeks in, preparing my first board meeting, the bookings number in the deck changed. My CEO, name withheld, had added a large, non-binding email from a prospect. When I pushed back, he said: "I am the CEO and I decide what a booking is." I resigned on the spot.
Who else knows?
My first week in a new FP&A job at name withheld. The handover included a $20m gap between the corporate target and the real budget. I asked who else knew. Nobody. Every month, my predecessor had posted a credit to make the numbers match, hoping the savings would turn up later. Five months in, about $7m was already sitting on the balance sheet.
Some challenges ahead
Before the board meeting, our VP of Engineering, name withheld, told me the launch would slip 90 days, at best. In the meeting, the CEO told the board there were some challenges ahead and an elite team was on it. I said nothing.
The product we sold twice
Two of us forecast revenue for name withheld, each our own piece. We both included the same product. Nobody noticed. The forecast went up the chain, and we had to go to leadership and explain how we'd sold it twice.
They just stopped deciding
2008. I was CFO of name withheld, a sales training company with Fortune 1000 clients. Before our revenue dropped, something quieter happened. Clients didn't cancel. They just postponed decisions, waiting for more certainty. Revenue fell in 2008 and 2009, and only turned in 2010.
The $50m favour
Three months into a new CFO job at name withheld, in the middle of a cash crisis, I found out the CEO and the VP of Sales had given our biggest customer 30 extra days to pay. For a few points of growth. Nobody asked finance. It cost us almost $50m in working capital, half our cash headroom. I took a red pen to the 13-week forecast and crossed out $50m in every single week. They reversed the deal.
Who else knows?
My first week in a new FP&A job at name withheld. The handover included a $20m gap between the corporate target and the real budget. I asked who else knew. Nobody. Every month, my predecessor had posted a credit to make the numbers match, hoping the savings would turn up later. Five months in, about $7m was already sitting on the balance sheet.
The product we sold twice
Two of us forecast revenue for name withheld, each our own piece. We both included the same product. Nobody noticed. The forecast went up the chain, and we had to go to leadership and explain how we'd sold it twice.
"I decide what a booking is"
Six weeks in, preparing my first board meeting, the bookings number in the deck changed. My CEO, name withheld, had added a large, non-binding email from a prospect. When I pushed back, he said: "I am the CEO and I decide what a booking is." I resigned on the spot.
Some challenges ahead
Before the board meeting, our VP of Engineering, name withheld, told me the launch would slip 90 days, at best. In the meeting, the CEO told the board there were some challenges ahead and an elite team was on it. I said nothing.
They just stopped deciding
2008. I was CFO of name withheld, a sales training company with Fortune 1000 clients. Before our revenue dropped, something quieter happened. Clients didn't cancel. They just postponed decisions, waiting for more certainty. Revenue fell in 2008 and 2009, and only turned in 2010.
The $50m favour
Three months into a new CFO job at name withheld, in the middle of a cash crisis, I found out the CEO and the VP of Sales had given our biggest customer 30 extra days to pay. For a few points of growth. Nobody asked finance. It cost us almost $50m in working capital, half our cash headroom. I took a red pen to the 13-week forecast and crossed out $50m in every single week. They reversed the deal.
The product we sold twice
Two of us forecast revenue for name withheld, each our own piece. We both included the same product. Nobody noticed. The forecast went up the chain, and we had to go to leadership and explain how we'd sold it twice.
Some challenges ahead
Before the board meeting, our VP of Engineering, name withheld, told me the launch would slip 90 days, at best. In the meeting, the CEO told the board there were some challenges ahead and an elite team was on it. I said nothing.
Who else knows?
My first week in a new FP&A job at name withheld. The handover included a $20m gap between the corporate target and the real budget. I asked who else knew. Nobody. Every month, my predecessor had posted a credit to make the numbers match, hoping the savings would turn up later. Five months in, about $7m was already sitting on the balance sheet.
"I decide what a booking is"
Six weeks in, preparing my first board meeting, the bookings number in the deck changed. My CEO, name withheld, had added a large, non-binding email from a prospect. When I pushed back, he said: "I am the CEO and I decide what a booking is." I resigned on the spot.
They just stopped deciding
2008. I was CFO of name withheld, a sales training company with Fortune 1000 clients. Before our revenue dropped, something quieter happened. Clients didn't cancel. They just postponed decisions, waiting for more certainty. Revenue fell in 2008 and 2009, and only turned in 2010.
New confessions, once a month.
Just the stories, straight to your inbox. Your email is never linked to a confession.

Overheard in the confessional
“You do know we have no cash, right?”
Head of Treasury to a new CFO, a few days in. Case 007.
YOUR TURN
Get it off your chest.
Real stories from finance people about the moment they found out too late, each with the early signal behind it. Read them, or add your own: a few lines, fully anonymous.
01
What happened
02
The context
03
Send it
How we handle your confession
Functionally zero
A few days into a new CFO job, my Head of Treasury, name withheld, said: "You do know we have no cash, right?" The balance sheet said about $100m. Some $20m sat in escrow from an old deal. Most of the rest was stuck: in an overseas subsidiary I didn't control, in cash-backed guarantees, in floats across 100+ bank accounts. Usable cash: zero. I'd never felt so poor.
Slick, smart, wrong room
I built a profit-contribution analysis by region at name withheld. It showed one region was basically carrying the other two. I presented it to all the sales leaders, feeling really slick and smart. Two of them weren't fans of mine. The meeting turned into a fight about my assumptions instead of the underperformance. I took it personally.
The 3AM board update
Four weeks into my first Group CFO role at name withheld, my trusty one-page planning sheet had grown into seven or eight stapled A3s. Then the 3AM wake-ups started. Eyes open, heart racing, realising I'd forgotten something critical in a board update we'd published six hours earlier.
Flat-footed on a Friday
Thursday, I was texting about SVB and still didn't think our deposits were at risk. Friday, the bank was shut. Our customers' data feeds went dark, dozens of them needed answers, and our own cash at name withheld was there too. I drew on an untapped venture-debt line to cover payroll. Looking back, I probably should have read SVB's audited financials.
Every board member in two hours
March 2023. SVB failed, and our operating account was there. Within two or three hours, every board member had called me, asking why the bank's website kept locking us out. We had no backup account. My controller, name withheld, emailed every customer: please don't pay us yet. The money was safe. Getting to it wasn't. It was a very harrowing week.
Functionally zero
A few days into a new CFO job, my Head of Treasury, name withheld, said: "You do know we have no cash, right?" The balance sheet said about $100m. Some $20m sat in escrow from an old deal. Most of the rest was stuck: in an overseas subsidiary I didn't control, in cash-backed guarantees, in floats across 100+ bank accounts. Usable cash: zero. I'd never felt so poor.
The 3AM board update
Four weeks into my first Group CFO role at name withheld, my trusty one-page planning sheet had grown into seven or eight stapled A3s. Then the 3AM wake-ups started. Eyes open, heart racing, realising I'd forgotten something critical in a board update we'd published six hours earlier.
Every board member in two hours
March 2023. SVB failed, and our operating account was there. Within two or three hours, every board member had called me, asking why the bank's website kept locking us out. We had no backup account. My controller, name withheld, emailed every customer: please don't pay us yet. The money was safe. Getting to it wasn't. It was a very harrowing week.
Slick, smart, wrong room
I built a profit-contribution analysis by region at name withheld. It showed one region was basically carrying the other two. I presented it to all the sales leaders, feeling really slick and smart. Two of them weren't fans of mine. The meeting turned into a fight about my assumptions instead of the underperformance. I took it personally.
Flat-footed on a Friday
Thursday, I was texting about SVB and still didn't think our deposits were at risk. Friday, the bank was shut. Our customers' data feeds went dark, dozens of them needed answers, and our own cash at name withheld was there too. I drew on an untapped venture-debt line to cover payroll. Looking back, I probably should have read SVB's audited financials.
Functionally zero
A few days into a new CFO job, my Head of Treasury, name withheld, said: "You do know we have no cash, right?" The balance sheet said about $100m. Some $20m sat in escrow from an old deal. Most of the rest was stuck: in an overseas subsidiary I didn't control, in cash-backed guarantees, in floats across 100+ bank accounts. Usable cash: zero. I'd never felt so poor.
Every board member in two hours
March 2023. SVB failed, and our operating account was there. Within two or three hours, every board member had called me, asking why the bank's website kept locking us out. We had no backup account. My controller, name withheld, emailed every customer: please don't pay us yet. The money was safe. Getting to it wasn't. It was a very harrowing week.
Flat-footed on a Friday
Thursday, I was texting about SVB and still didn't think our deposits were at risk. Friday, the bank was shut. Our customers' data feeds went dark, dozens of them needed answers, and our own cash at name withheld was there too. I drew on an untapped venture-debt line to cover payroll. Looking back, I probably should have read SVB's audited financials.
The 3AM board update
Four weeks into my first Group CFO role at name withheld, my trusty one-page planning sheet had grown into seven or eight stapled A3s. Then the 3AM wake-ups started. Eyes open, heart racing, realising I'd forgotten something critical in a board update we'd published six hours earlier.
Slick, smart, wrong room
I built a profit-contribution analysis by region at name withheld. It showed one region was basically carrying the other two. I presented it to all the sales leaders, feeling really slick and smart. Two of them weren't fans of mine. The meeting turned into a fight about my assumptions instead of the underperformance. I took it personally.
THE SMALL PRINT
How the confessional works.
You write a few sentences. We read it, rewrite it so nobody can be identified, and add it to the confessional as a numbered case file. You never give a name, an email address or a company.
Peaky runs this series. Peaky builds software for finance teams, so we know this problem. After each confession we add a short note on the early signal behind it. Your words are never used to sell.
Stuck? Start with where you were when you found out. Who told you, and how late? What number did you have to explain, and to whom? What did you say in that meeting, and what did you think?
Role, size and sector only feed the tag on the card, like “CFO, 200 to 500 employees, logistics”. They are banded on purpose, so nobody can be identified.
Our promise
We never ask for your name or email in this form.
We rewrite every confession. If it still points at a person or company, we do not publish it.
We never use your answer for sales or to find out who you are.
Unpublished answers are deleted after 30 days.
The series is run by Peaky.
After you send it, we read it, rewrite it so nobody can be identified, and we may publish it as a confession. Follow Peaky on LinkedIn to see if yours comes up. Know a colleague with something to get off their chest? Share this page.